Formal Objection to Crag Lane Development - Update

Fri, 2014-08-22 16:26 -- contenteditor

Updated 8th Jan 2015

It was confirmed today by the planning inspectorate that the appeal was successful and planning was granted.

Please see the full decision document below.

Updated 1st Nov 2014

The reapplication to Harrogate Council was rejected again.

Updated 1st Sept 2014

As well as appealing to Secretary of State for CLG Taylor Wimpey have also resubmitted their application to Harrogate Council. Details can be found via  using reference 14/03471/OUTMAJ. 

The contractors own bat survey confirms the 4 species of bats and risks that the development presents at

You can make your views known on this site. Please note that you will need to set up an account again due to a problem with the site.


Updated 17th August 2014

An appeal has been made by Taylor Wimpey to the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government. A copy of the letter confirming can be found here.

Details of the full objection can be found here on the Planning Portal. You can also add your own thoughts and objections on the same site that we would encourage you to do.

You can also read an open letter to Harrogate Council planning from a bat ecologist on the bat situation within the Pinewoods confirming the importance of the site and increasing numbers.


Updated 8th April 2014: Following a planning meeting today the application as below was rejected 16 to 0. Thank you to all our supporters who voiced their objections.

The Pinewoods Conservation Group (PCG) has submitted a formal objection to the Crag Lane housing development. Taylor Wimpey recently submitted plans for 124 dwellings to be built on green space at Crag lane, adjacent to The Pinewoods and RHS Harlow Carr that the PCG have reviewed.

The group has considered the Ecological and Bio Diversity elements of the plans and has raised a number of concerns. These include the risk to protected species of bats that are resident within the Pinewoods as well as the impact on the various birds and wildlife around the proposed site.

Secretary Michelle Whitfield-Speed confirmed “After careful consideration of the plans, and with a direct impact on The Pinewoods we had no option but to submit a formal objection. There is clear evidence that the surrounding environment and wildlife will be severely impacted should this planning be approved.

The land in question is not earmarked for development in the Local Development Framework and is designated as a special landscape area. As such we call on Harrogate Council to reject this application.”

Harrogate residents who are concerned about this development and the future conservation of The Pinewoods are encouraged to join the Pinewoods Conservation Group via

A full copy of the objection can be found below.


Dear Sirs,

Re: Planning Ref 14/00259/OUTMAJ – Housing on Crag Lane

I am writing on behalf of Pinewoods Conservation Group (PCG) regarding the proposed planning development of 124 dwellings on Crag Lane.  As we feel this development would directly and permanently impact on The Pinewoods in a negative manner we would like to formally object to the application.

The Pinewoods consists of around 96 acres of woodland situated adjacent to the site. The Pinewoods form a key link from Valley Gardens to RHS Harlow Carr, the 2 largest tourist attractions in Harrogate. The PCG is a registered charity whose main objective is to promote the maintenance and conservation of The Pinewoods. As such these plans are contrary to our objectives.

I suspect that many other objections will be received that will focus on the general issues regarding these plans including; traffic and access issues, lack of general infrastructure, concerns on drainage and flooding, impact on Police response times and the area not being included in the Local Development Framework as a preferred site. However, our main concern is the negative impact on the ecology, diversity and sustainability of The Pinewoods and surrounding areas.

Although we note that the application includes the mandatory biodiversity check lists and ecological surveys these could be seen as misleading and in cases are factually incorrect (i.e. refers to 109 dwelling).  We would also dispute the Biodiversity check list that indicates that no protected species surveys are required with regards to impact upon woodland and field hedgerows.

As such they should be reviewed further. As such our main points of concern are as below:

  • Special Landscape Area: The site is currently outside the development limit and within a Special Landscape Area. The site is part of a “green wedge” that extends from the town centre to the south-west. With dwellings down the long side of Pinewoods the vista will be severely restricted with natural light into the woods also reduced.  As such it is essential that this area remains undeveloped to ensure this green lung of Harrogate remains intact.
  • Birds:  The applicants own ecological survey makes reference to the wide and varied species of birds that can be identified in the area, some of which are protected and notable. This open space adjacent to woodland is a key area for birds to feed and nest. Development of this land would ensure this is lost for ever. The presence of Owls should also be noted that is not mentioned within the report.
  • Bats: The ecological survey makes reference to evidence of bats. The PCG can confirm that Pipistrelles bats do exist within The Pinewoods and in substantial numbers. Recent surveys carried out by licenced bat handlers have identified over 20 bats within erected bat boxes within The Pinewoods. Actual numbers with natural roosting habitats could be much higher. Evidence of bats being present during hibernation seasons has also been identified. These bats can be seen using the proposed site for feeding so will be impacted by any development. The report itself acknowledges that the site would be a good source of foraging for bats. These bats are accepted by H.M.Government as an environment performance indicator and as well as being protected species should be seen are permanent residents of the area. The Natural England consultation reply highlights the standing advice that should be adopted should protected species be evident. It should also be noted that a number of bat boxes are on the perimeter of the site.
  • Badgers: The ecological survey suggests no evidence of Badgers on the site or within 2km. Any regular visitor to the area will know this not to be the case and further details can be supplied confidentially due to the sensitive nature.  As such further recommendations should be made to address the impact on this species.
  • Established Trees: A number of established trees and their roots may be impacted by these plans, a number of which are protected by Tree Protection Orders. The councils own arboricultural report covers the concerns more fully and notes the “Saved” Policy HD13 Trees and Woodland that protects against proposals that would involve the loss of trees or woodland.
  • Hedgerow: Impact on hedgerows is identified as a concern within the report where it is acknowledged that their removal could impact on nesting birds. These hedgerows will also support a wider range of ecology that is not acknowledged within the report. The loss of any established hedgerow will take many years to be replaced.
  • Light Pollution: The site if developed will introduce unnatural light to The Pinewoods. This will have a negative impact on the wildlife within it, especially those of a nocturnal nature.

It can be clearly seen that approval of this site would have a severe detrimental impact on the surrounding area and nature, not only within the site but around it. As such it should be fully rejected.

Yours faithfully,


Neil Hind

Vice Chair of Pinewoods Conservation Group

On Behalf of Pinewoods Conservation Group Committee

Join us in conserving and protecting our local area.

Help us to care for the natural habitat within and around Harrogate.

Tweet us